Being Gay Isn’t a Choice, But Hating Someone Is—Here’s Why

by | August 15, 2025 | Time 5 mins

At Pride events across the world, bold signs speak louder than any megaphone. One sign, simple but cutting, has captured attention online and in the streets: Being gay isn’t a choice, but being hateful is. It is more than a catchy protest slogan. It is a distilled truth backed by decades of scientific research, psychology, and lived experience.

Hate is not a natural part of the human condition. Babies are not born homophobic. Children are not born with a fear of two men holding hands. Prejudice, especially against LGBTQ+ people, is a learned behavior, passed down through social conditioning, fear-based narratives, and cultural structures designed to protect outdated norms.

Understanding the psychology of hate is critical because prejudice does not just happen — it is built, brick by brick, over years. And like anything learned, it can be unlearned. This is a journey that challenges deep-seated beliefs and often requires people to question the very foundations of their worldview.

This is not about convincing bigots to love everyone. It is about exposing the mechanisms of hate so people can recognize it, reject it, and dismantle it.

Being Gay Isn’t a Choice, But Hating Someone Is—Here’s Why

Hate is Learned, Not Innate

The American Psychological Association has long held that sexual orientation is not a choice. The same cannot be said for hatred toward LGBTQ+ people. Hate is a social construct, and it is taught, consciously or unconsciously, by families, peers, religious institutions, and political leaders.

Research from Harvard University shows that implicit biases form in early childhood, often before children can fully articulate their beliefs. These biases are absorbed through observation — watching how adults react to LGBTQ+ people, hearing the language they use, and noting what topics are avoided or framed negatively.

In other words, a child who grows up hearing that “being gay is wrong” is not born believing it. They learn it from their environment. And if that child grows up in a space where LGBTQ+ existence is celebrated, they are far less likely to internalize homophobia.

This principle is not exclusive to sexuality. Studies on racial prejudice and gender bias show the same patterns. Hatred is not innate. It is nurtured.

The Role of Fear and the “Other”

Humans have a psychological tendency to categorize people into “us” and “them.” In evolutionary history, this instinct helped early humans identify potential threats. In modern society, it often leads to irrational prejudices against people who are different.

Fear of the “other” is amplified when people lack exposure to diversity. When someone has never met an openly gay person, their image of what it means to be gay is shaped entirely by media portrayals, religious teachings, or political rhetoric — sources that can distort reality for ideological purposes.

Historically, LGBTQ+ people have been portrayed as dangerous, immoral, or mentally ill. These portrayals are not based on fact. They are based on fear-mongering narratives that make it easier to justify discrimination. The less a community interacts with openly LGBTQ+ people, the easier it is for false stereotypes to take root.

This fear becomes the breeding ground for hate. Once established, it can be maintained for generations if never challenged.

Hate as a Tool of Power

Prejudice is not just personal bias. It is a powerful tool used to maintain existing social hierarchies.

Religious and political leaders have long weaponized anti-LGBTQ+ sentiment to unify supporters, distract from economic or governance issues, and preserve traditional gender roles. By framing LGBTQ+ rights as a “threat” to societal order, those in power reinforce their own authority.

The concept of heteronormativity — the assumption that heterosexuality is the default or “normal” state — plays a central role in this. It is embedded in laws, workplace policies, educational curriculums, and even pop culture. Anything outside this norm is treated as deviant or dangerous, which helps keep the status quo in place.

When people buy into this system, consciously or unconsciously, they are choosing to support structures that harm LGBTQ+ people. And that choice can be reversed.

How Hate is Reinforced

Hate does not survive in isolation. It thrives in echo chambers.

Social media platforms can create bubbles where misinformation spreads unchecked. A person who already holds homophobic views can easily find online communities that reinforce their beliefs and shut out opposing perspectives.

Mass media can also contribute to this reinforcement. When television shows, movies, or news outlets frame LGBTQ+ issues as “controversial” rather than human rights, they legitimize the idea that there is something debatable about LGBTQ+ existence.

Policies and laws that allow discrimination — whether in housing, employment, or healthcare — also send a message that prejudice is socially acceptable. In countries where being gay is criminalized, legal systems become enablers of hate.

These reinforcements do not happen by accident. They are maintained through choices: the choice to consume certain media, the choice to follow certain influencers, the choice to vote for candidates with anti-LGBTQ+ platforms.

Breaking the Cycle of Hate

If hate is learned, it can be unlearned. But this process is neither quick nor easy.

It starts with exposure to difference. Research consistently shows that people who personally know LGBTQ+ individuals are far less likely to hold prejudiced views. Direct interaction breaks down stereotypes and replaces fear with understanding.

Education plays a pivotal role as well. Comprehensive LGBTQ+ education in schools not only benefits queer students but also fosters empathy in their peers. Public awareness campaigns, literature, and inclusive media representation all chip away at ignorance.

However, the most important factor is personal accountability. Unlearning hate requires individuals to actively challenge their own biases. It demands questioning the sources of information they trust, listening to marginalized voices, and making conscious choices to reject bigotry even when it is socially or politically convenient to stay silent.

The Choice to Hate

At its core, hate is not an uncontrollable emotion. It is a decision to hold on to fear, prejudice, and misinformation, even when there is ample evidence to the contrary.

No one can choose their sexual orientation. But everyone can choose whether to perpetuate harm against LGBTQ+ people. Those who cling to hatred do so because it serves them in some way — validating their worldview, aligning them with their in-group, or protecting them from confronting uncomfortable truths.

Recognizing hate as a choice strips away the excuses. It means no one can hide behind “that’s just how I was raised” or “it’s my belief system.” Beliefs can change. People can evolve. And when they do, societies transform.

Choosing Compassion Over Hate

The sign at Pride could not be more accurate. Being gay is not a choice. Being hateful is.

The psychology of hate is not mysterious. It is built from fear, ignorance, and systems of power — and sustained through individual and collective decisions. The same mechanisms that create prejudice can also dismantle it.

Choosing compassion over hate is not just a personal decision. It is a societal necessity. Every time someone challenges a harmful stereotype, calls out discrimination, or refuses to participate in prejudice, they are making a choice that shapes the future.

If hate can be taught, so can love. The only question is what people will choose to pass on to the next generation.

Rate this post

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 5 / 5. Vote count: 3

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

0 Comments

Brian Webb

Brian Webb

Author

Brian Webb is the founder and editor-in-chief of HomoCulture, a celebrated content creator, and winner of the prestigious Mr. Gay Canada – People’s Choice award. An avid traveler, Brian attends Pride events, festivals, street fairs, and LGBTQ friendly destinations through the HomoCulture Tour. He has developed a passion for discovering and sharing authentic lived experiences, educating about the LGBTQ community, and using both his photography and storytelling to produce inspiring content. Originally from the beautiful Okanagan Valley in the southern interior of British Columbia, Brian now lives in Vancouver, British Columbia. His personal interests include travel, photography, physical fitness, mixology, drag shows.

Check Out These Recent Posts

Artificial Hearts and Real Feelings in Gay Dating Apps

Artificial Hearts and Real Feelings in Gay Dating Apps

Artificial intelligence is learning to flirt—and that’s raising eyebrows across the gay dating world. From auto-generated messages to virtual wingmen, tech is slowly slipping into the space where real attraction once lived. The rise of AI in gay dating...

read more
Should Small City Pride Events Keep Going Or Go Regional

Should Small City Pride Events Keep Going Or Go Regional

Pride is booming in places that once had none. From prairie towns to coastal villages, organizers are building parades, picnics, and community stages with grit and love. The question keeps popping up in planning meetings and city halls: small city Pride...

read more

Join our newsletter

GDPR